Jag Venugopal's Blog

December 20, 2010

No Longer A PMP

Filed under: Project Management — Jag @ 12:12 pm

I recently received an email from the Project Management Institute that my PMP credential was “suspended”, preventing me from calling myself a Project Management Professional. The reason for the suspension was that I had not turned in documentation for the 60 PDUs that are required in each 3 year cycle for keeping the PMP certificate current.

Over the past few years, I have become disillusioned by PMI’s total commercialization. Anyone who considers the Project Management Institute to be a not-for-profit organization dedicated to advancing the cause of project management is thoroughly mistaken. PMI has instead turned itself into a commercial entity that sells a suite of goods and services centered around the PMBOK and the PMP.

My disenchantment with PMI started with the third edition of the PMBOK, published in 2004, which was a disaster. PMI should have had the fortitude to revoke the standard, or issue a significant revision. They did neither, and were content to peddle a sub-standard book masquerading as an ANSI standard. The fourth edition was much cleaner, but PMI’s process of producing what purports to be a global standard for a profession leaves many questions open — is this reviewed by leading practitioners, authors and trainers? Who reviews the documents other than the people that respond to the exposure draft on the web? (Practitioners and authors with extensive project management knowledge and experience are busy, and are the ones least likely to respond to the exposure drafts; yet their feedback is arguably the most valuable).

Additionally, PMI’s contributions to project management (other than the PMBOK) have been fairly minimal. There are a bunch of practice standards, which are all derivative publications of the PMBOK, but in the last decade and a half that I have known about the PMI, not a single new project management concept or innovation has come from the organization. To my mind, PMI has never satisfactorily addressed the question of whether Project Management is unique across industries or if it means different things for different industries. For example, in software, the very ability to change software already written has given rise to a number of “agile” methodologies which are diametrically different from the PMBOK approach.

I have come to see PMI’s business as the selling of certificates, along with accessory materials such as learning aids, training manuals, accreditation of trainers, etc. Indeed, advertisements for various exam-related paraphernalia are prominent on the PMI web site. Missing are any mentions of tools or techniques that actually help project managers. On the website, there are a variety of certificates to be “purchased”: CAPM, PMP, PgMP, PMI-RP, PMI-SP, etc. At least as far as the PMP is concerned, the certificate attests to nothing but the ability of the holder to pass a 200-question multiple-choice examination. A memorizing monkey could do it — without needing to have a clue about project management.

True project management (at least of the IS kind that I am familiar with) is tough. It requires finely balancing among multiple constraints (the obvious being time, cost, scope, resources, quality and risk), the ability to fight multiple political battles simultaneously, the art of making the right compromises, and knowing when to push individuals to perform better and when to trust that they are doing as well as they can. And we’re not even started yet about the need for domain knowledge, IT knowledge, and finally, knowledge of project management tools and techniques. The PMP measures only the last area — and that too very incompletely, with multiple-choice questions. It most certainly does not measure or correlate with real-world project management ability. Other than for novice project managers, it is a total waste of time and money.

And so it is that I am now an ex-PMP.


Leave a Comment »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: